Shopping Cart Items: 0   Sub-Total : US$0.00

British Brodie Pattern Helmet: A Reenactor's Notes on the Mk I

British Brodie Pattern Helmet: A Reenactor's Notes on the Mk I
1 October 2026

The first time I wore a British Brodie Pattern Helmet at an event it was a raw autumn morning and I swear I could feel the cold of the steel through the liner. Daft, really. But that's the Brodie helmet for you, a shallow pressed bowl with a wide brim that looks like nothing else on the Western Front, and once it's on your head you stop feeling like a bloke in fancy dress.

This post is about the shop's reproduction of the Mk I, the pattern issued from 1916, and about the original it copies. I'll get the purist question out of the way first. The shell isn't a new pressing. It's a refinished Mk II shell, the Second World War version, fitted with a completely new liner and chinstrap made by WPG. More on whether that matters further down.

Where the Brodie Helmet Came From

The French got there first. A steel helmet had been issued to French troops in the spring of 1915, and the War Office looked hard at their design before deciding it was too complex to get out quickly and didn't offer enough protection. In September 1915 a design patented by John Brodie was picked instead. The Imperial War Museum's notes say the second experimental type, "B", was approved. Type A only lasted a few weeks in production before Type B arrived in October 1915.

The big selling point was manufacture. Brodie's shell could be cut from a single sheet of steel and pressed into its soup bowl shape, which made it stronger and easier to produce. Sir Robert Hadfield pushed for a 12% manganese steel, and the first helmets came out of his works in Sheffield. (If you've turned an original over and seen "HS" stamped under the brim, that's Hadfield's steel with a lot number after it.)

Supply was thin at first. The early helmets were treated as trench stores, not personal kit, with something like 50 per battalion considered enough. By March 1916 roughly 140,000 had gone out to the Western Front, still nowhere near one per man. They first turned up in any numbers at the Somme in July 1916.

From Trench Stores to the Mk I

Not everyone loved it. General Plumer reportedly thought the early helmet was too shallow, too reflective and too sharp at the rim, with a lining that let it slip about.

So the Mk I dealt with most of that. According to the IWM it started to be issued around May 1916, with a two-part liner and a thin mild steel folded rim to cover the raw edge, and by September the name "Helmet, Steel, Mark I" had stuck. The paint went matte khaki, finished with sand, sawdust or crushed cork so it wouldn't catch the light.

The liner is where it gets interesting if you're a rivet counter like me. The IWM describes one original Mk I liner with an oval crown pad of lint, asbestos and felt, an American cloth headband over netting, and a row of 12 tubular rubber buffers, the lot held to the crown by a single copper rivet. Another collector writing about his Mk I describes a rubber donut, with a leather strap riveted at the top running through it and on down to become the chinstrap. Liners varied. And there were mongrels too, because leftover parts were used up, so you get earlier shells married to the newer liner.

Lined, a Mk I came in at about 2.4 pounds. Not much on paper. After a day in a trench it feels like more.

Doughboys, the Next War and the Turtle

The Americans started out with it too. When the AEF arrived in 1917 its men were first issued British Mk Is (those serving with French units got Adrians), and American production of the M1917 copy reached about 2.7 million by the end of the war. The quick tell is the rim: overlapped on the British helmet, butted on the American.

Between the wars the shape stayed. From 1936 the Mk I got an improved liner and an elasticated, sprung chinstrap, and in late 1940 the slightly modified Mk II took over and served British and Commonwealth forces through the Second World War. Police, fire services and ARP used the same shape at home. The Mk III "turtle" eventually started replacing it from 1944.

Does a Mk II Shell Matter?

For most of us, no. The IWM points out that the basic shape stayed in service with changes to the liner and finish until the end of the Second World War, which is exactly why a Mk II shell can be turned back into a Great War lid.

Would a sharp-eyed collector with an original in his other hand spot details? Possibly, and I'd rather say so than pretend otherwise. But I'd take what the British Brodie Pattern Helmet gives you, a real steel Mk II shell, refinished, with a new WPG liner and chinstrap, over a thin modern pressing any day. It has the right heft on your head and the right ring when someone knocks on it (and someone always knocks on it).

Wearing the British Brodie Pattern Helmet at Events

The obvious use is any British or Commonwealth Western Front impression from mid-1916 to the Armistice. Doing early 1915? Leave it in the car, you'd be in a cap. It also works for a 1917 American impression before the M1917s came through, which is a nice niche if your group does doughboys.

A few things I'd pass on:

  • Several buyers say it sits high. There's a fix, see the reviews below.
  • Don't over-age it. The paint on the British Brodie Pattern Helmet already looks right, and a battered helmet on a fresh 1916 tunic looks wrong.
  • No cover comes with it, so sort one separately if your impression needs it.

Anyway. It's the bit of kit the public recognise first.

What Our Customers Say About It

One buyer with an original to compare called it "Easily one of the best Brodie replicas out there" and said "the paint is spot on, you don't need to artificially age it to make it believable." Another wrote "Perfect for WWI British reenacting. Exactly the helmet I needed." It's gone into displays as well: "Bought the Brodie helmets for use in Museum exhibits."

On fit, the honest picture. One buyer said "I would suggest ordering a size larger. I wear a 7 1/4 and it sits a little high and tight on my head." Another found the cause in "a piece of flexible fuel hose on the repro" inside the crown, and explained how a bit of "keyhole surgery" got it out, leaving a repro "which fits low on the head". Not everything was perfect either, one buyer noted "A gap in the folded rim leaving a small 'bite'". You can read every review on the British Brodie Pattern Helmet reviews page.

Disclaimer: Historical information provided for educational purposes only. For accurate product specifications and details, please check our product pages, reviews, or contact customer service.

Experience a piece of history for yourself! Check out our authentic reproduction of British Brodie Pattern Helmets here: Get Your British Brodie Pattern Helmets

Comments

Leave a comment
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
0 Item(s)
US$0.00